Physical Activity, Weight Loss and Weight Regain

Research: The new American College of Sports Medicine position stand.

Donnelly, J.E., et al. 2009. Appropriate physical activity intervention strategies for weight loss and prevention of weight regain for adults. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 41 (2), 459-71.

The recent American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) position stand on physical activity intervention strategies for weight loss reflects an update from the previous guidelines, synthesizing all published data–based research from 1999 to the beginning of 2009.

This compilation of physical activity and weight management research includes individuals ≥18 years of age, although the authors note there is a need for more weight loss studies on older populations (≥65 years). Investigations involving subjects with disorders such as cardiovascular disease, hypertension and type 2 diabetes are included because these health troubles are reflective of the overweight/obese U.S. society. The quantification of exercise intensity is presented in the form of METs (metabolic equivalents of a task). One MET is the equivalent of 3.5 milliliters per kilogram (of body weight) per minute (ml/kg/min) and is considered a resting level of oxygen consumption. Light-intensity activity is quantified as 1.1–2.9 METs, moderate- intensity activity as 3.0–5.9 METs and vigorous activity as ≥6 METs.

Overweight and Obesity

Presently, 66.3% of U.S. citizens are either overweight (body mass index [BMI] = 25–29.9 kg/m2) and/or obese (BMI ≥ 30 kg/m2). In these people, weight loss of as little as 3%–5% of body weight (although a 10% reduction is encouraged) has been shown to improve high-density lipoproteins (the good cholesterol) and glucose metabolism, while decreasing triglycerides (blood fats) and other risk factors of cardiovascular disease (Donnelly et al. 2009). However, despite these impressive health benefits from weight loss, it is clear that the U.S. is not going to reach its Healthy People 2010 initiative for reducing the prevalence of obesity (see the sidebar “Initiatives and Campaigns to Reduce Obesity”).

Weight Maintenance and the Prevention of Weight Gain

In the new ACSM position stand, weight maintenance is defined as a <3% change in body weight, whereas an increase of >5% in body weight is considered clinically significant. (The term clinical implies a medical observation, treatment, practice or diagnosis.) It is clear from all of the research and from leading medical/scientific organizations (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, ACSM, the American Heart Association and the American Medical Association) that more physical activity is needed for most persons. The recent research indicates that 150–250 minutes per week of moderately vigorous physical activity, at an energy equivalent of ~1,200–2,000 kilocalories (kcal) per week (about 12–20 miles per week of jogging or running), is sufficient for preventing weight gain greater than 3%.

Amount of Physical Activity Needed for Clinically Significant Weight Loss

It is recognized that most studies showing clinically significant weight loss (5% of body weight) demonstrate this using energy restriction (i.e., eating fewer calories) combined with physical activity to create a larger negative energy balance (i.e., more calories expended than consumed). That noted, the research shows that physical activity lasting <150 minutes per week has a minimal effect on weight loss. Physical activity lasting >150 minutes per week usually results in modest weight loss (defined as ~2–3 kg), while physical activity lasting 225–420 minutes per week results in the greatest weight loss (5–7.5 kg).

Weight Regain After Weight Loss

It appears that most individuals are capable of losing weight, with the long-standing challenge being how to maintain the reduction. Consistent physical activity is the best predictor of sustained weight management following weight loss. And, when it comes to preventing weight regain, this position stand reports that some research specifies that study subjects who had lost >10% of their body weight after 24 months were participating in 275 minutes of physical activity per week. However, due to research methodology design flaws, there is currently no definitive answer as to how much exercise is needed to prevent weight regain. Donnelly and colleagues suggest that approximately 60 minutes per day (about 4 miles/day) at a moderate intensity is a likely minimum.

No More Confusion: Lifestyle Approaches vs. Lifestyle Forms of Physical Activity

Lifestyle forms of physical activity include types of movement that are not organized approaches to exercise. Lifestyle forms comprise the spontaneous physical activities an individual does during the day (e.g., walking from the car to a store, walking to the chair at a theater, walking in a grocery store, etc.). On the other hand, lifestyle approaches include participation in organized exercise, leisure time physical activity, occupational physical activity, household physical activity and physical activity for commuting (e.g., bicycling). Numerous studies point out that lifestyle approaches to increased physical activity are quite effective for preventing initial weight gain. Unfortunately, most adults spend most of their time sitting. The more active a person is, the less likely it is that he or she will become obese.

Effectiveness of “Diet Only” vs. “Diet Plus Exercise” for Weight Loss

Most studies demonstrate that when diet (caloric restriction) and physical activity are combined in a weight management program, weight loss results are encouraging. Donnelly and colleagues (2009) explain that a weight loss program design may create an energy deficit (e.g., 500–1,500 kcal per day) composed of exercise (e.g., 250 kcal per day) and caloric restriction (e.g., 250 kcal per day) for the daily caloric deficit total (500 kcal in this example). In studies where investigators introduce an energy deficit of 700–1,000 kcal per day, “diet only” and “diet plus exercise” result in similar losses. Donnelly explains that this is due to metabolic adaptations that “diminish any additive effect of the energy expenditure from physical activity on weight loss.” However, in investigations where the energy deficit is 500–700 kcal per day, the “diet plus exercise” group sees more weight loss, by about 20%, than the “diet only” intervention.

The Role of Resistance Exercise in Significant Weight Loss

Consistent resistance training provides numerous health-related benefits, including increases in insulin sensitivity, higher levels of HDL-C (the healthy cholesterol), reductions in blood glucose levels, lower levels of LDL-C (the bad cholesterol) and cardiovascular-disease risk reduction. The increase in muscle mass from resistance exercise has been shown to elevate resting metabolic rate in some persons. Some resistance training programs elicit increased fat oxidation (burning) after the workout (as the body uses additional energy to restore cell processes to homeostasis). Exercise programs combining aerobic training and resistance exercise exhibit superior results for weight and fat loss. In “diet plus resistance training” programs, the addition of resistance training promotes the preservation and/or increase of fat-free mass.

Let’s Put It Together

As exercise professionals, the evidence continues to mount that our first goal is to get clients active, with continuing efforts to get students doing more endurance exercise at a more challenging intensity. Regular resistance training is a must for the maintenance and/or increase of fat-free mass. Donnelly et al. (2009) recommend 250–300 minutes per week (~2,000 kcal per week) of moderate-intensity exercise for greater weight loss and prevention of weight gain. We can do it!

For the latest research, statistics, sample classes, and more, "Like" IDEA on Facebook here.

Len Kravitz, PhD

IDEA Author/Presenter
Len Kravitz, PhD, is the program coordinator of exercise science and a researcher at the University ... more less
November 2009

© 2009 by IDEA Health & Fitness Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is strictly prohibited.

Get the award-winning IDEA Fitness Journal delivered to your door every month!

Get IDEA Fitness Journal

Article Comments

Add Comment

Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
View all questions