Do CPR Chest Compressions Trump Rescue Breaths?

by Joy Keller on May 01, 2007

Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) training is a requirement for reputable fitness certifications and has been recommended by the American Heart Association for healthcare professionals and the general public for more than 35 years. About 900 Americans die every day from sudden cardiac arrest, so it is always advisable to keep track of suggested changes in the CPR protocol. A recent study from Japan indicates that chest compressions, not mouth-to-mouth resuscitation, are the key to success in helping a victim of cardiac arrest.

In the study, which appeared in the March 17 edition of The Lancet (2007; 369, 920–26), researchers analyzed 4,068 adult patients whose cardiac arrest was witnessed by bystanders. Of those, 439 received only chest compressions from the bystanders, and 712 received conventional CPR (compressions and rescue breaths). Twenty-two percent of those who received just chest compressions survived with good neurological function, compared with only 10% of those who received combination CPR.

In 2005 the American Heart Association revised its CPR guidelines to put more emphasis on chest presses, recommending 30 instead of 15 for every two rescue breaths. The organization said that studies had shown that “effective chest compressions create more blood flow through the heart to the rest of the body, buying a few minutes until defibrillation can be attempted or the heart can pump blood on its own.” The new guidelines recommend that rescuers “push hard and push fast” when giving chest compressions. Another advantage to dropping the rescue breaths, according to a comment in The Lancet, is that it could make bystanders more willing to provide CPR in the first place.

A Yahoo! Health news report mentions a caveat: the combination CPR in the study was given according to the old guidelines of 15 presses for every two breaths, not the 30 presses recommended now. According to this same article, the American Heart Association does not expect its advice to change. It recommends that bystanders provide compression-only CPR if they are “unwilling or unable” to do mouth-to-mouth breathing at the same time.

To view the study and the comment on it, visit www.thelancet.com/webfiles/images/ clusters/thelancet/press_office/resusitation.pdf.

Want more from Joy Keller?

Fitness Journal, Volume 4, Issue 5

Find the Perfect Job

More jobs, more applicants and more visits than any other fitness industry job board.

© 2007 by IDEA Health & Fitness Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is strictly prohibited.

About the Author

Joy Keller

Joy Keller IDEA Author/Presenter

Joy Keller is executive editor of IDEA Fitness Journal and IDEA Fit Business Success, and is also a certified personal trainer, indoor cycling instructor, yoga teacher (RYT 200) and Reiki Master. Joy joined IDEA Health & Fitness Association in 2002, and brought with her a wealth of information about how to fine-tune communication channels, after having spent her formative career years specializing in business-to-business journalism. Before she even graduated with honors from the respected University of Georgia journalism school, Joy was offered a job at one of the most successful trade publishing companies in the southeast, Shore Varrone, Inc. She made her mark in the automotive aftermarket industry as a creative thinker and journalist with an intuitive knack for researching and understanding niche audiences. Joy has worked on several titles, including Auto Trim & Restyling News, Truck Accessory News, Digital Output Magazine, Retail & Construction News, Miata magazine, Ford Racing, and many more. Her passion, however, lies with health and fitness. She was the associate editor of ACE Certified News while working at the American Council on Exercise, and transitioned that publication from a newsletter to a magazine. She has enjoyed 16 years at IDEA, where she has launched several publications, including the award-winning Inner IDEA Body-Mind Spirit Review, IDEA Pilates Today and IDEA Fit Business Success. Joy is a content creator and media 2.0 advocate who takes pride in discovering the unique information needs of qualified audiences, and she is dedicated to serving those needs while following the highest available standards.