Leading Authentically

Member Exclusive Content

Sign up to be a member to access this content.

Join now!

Already a member? Login

Leadership in the fitness industry has always been demanding, but the current landscape has raised the stakes. Rising operational costs, pressures from stakeholders, evolving client expectations, and an industry-wide staffing challenges have forced leaders to navigate complexity with fewer buffers and less margin for error.

In this environment, leadership styles built on charisma, control, or top-down certainty are increasingly fragile. What sustains teams now is not perfection or bravado, but trust. And trust, in people-centered businesses like fitness and wellness, is built through authentic leadership practiced consistently.

What Authentic Leadership Really Means Here

Authentic leadership is often described using familiar terms: integrity, transparency, self-awareness, and purpose. While these concepts are well established, their application in the fitness industry carries unique implications.

Authenticity in our space is not about oversharing or informality. It shows up in alignment between stated values and daily decisions. It is visible in how leaders communicate during uncertainty, how they respond when plans change, and how they balance business realities with human impact.

In fitness environments, where work is personal, physical, and relational, inconsistency is quickly felt and seen. Teams notice when wellness is promoted externally but ignored internally. They notice when growth is prioritized over sustainability, or when transparency disappears during challenging moments. Authentic leadership is less about saying the right things and more about being predictably fair, clear, and accountable.

“Trust is built in very small moments.”
— Brené Brown

Leadership Tensions, Not Leadership Ideals

Authentic leadership is rarely tested when things are going well. It is tested in moments of tension, when there is no option that satisfies everyone.

Consider a common scenario: a necessary operational change that improves long-term viability but disrupts established routines or relationships. Leaders must decide how much information to share, how quickly to act, and how to support their teams through discomfort without overpromising certainty.

In these moments, authenticity does not guarantee approval. It does, however, preserve trust. Clear communication about what is known, what is still being evaluated, and what values are guiding decisions signals respect for the people affected. Avoiding difficult conversations may reduce short-term friction, but it often erodes credibility over time.

Authentic Leadership Is Behavioral, Not Positional

While executive leaders set tone and direction, authentic leadership is not limited to titles. In fitness organizations, influence often travels laterally and downward more than it does hierarchically.

Group instructors, fitness coaches and front desk staff in addition to department heads shape culture through everyday interactions: how feedback is delivered, how boundaries are modeled, and how consistency is maintained under pressure. Authentic leadership at these levels is expressed through follow-through, clarity, and the ability to hold both standards and empathy at the same time. When leaders at every level operate with alignment and self-awareness, organizations become more resilient. When authenticity is expected only at the top, disconnects emerge quickly.

Why This Matters Now

The fitness industry depends on trust: between leaders and teams, teams and customers, and organizations and the communities they serve. Authentic leadership strengthens that trust by reducing ambiguity and reinforcing shared responsibility.

In periods of rapid change, people are less concerned with leaders having all the answers and more concerned with leaders being honest about the process. Authentic leadership provides stability not by eliminating uncertainty, but by making it navigable.

Looking Ahead

Leadership in fitness is contextual, relational, and evolving. In the months ahead, this series will explore leadership under pressure, decision-making during uncertainty, and the practical work of building cultures that can sustain both performance and people.

Authentic leadership is not a personality trait. It is a practice. And in today’s fitness industry, it is one of the most powerful tools leaders have.