Exercise is for everyone!

Introducing ability—seeing the potential in special populations.

Take an in-depth look into a water garden or Japanese fish pond. For years, psychologists and sociologists have pointed to the brightly colored koi fish living in these gardens as an analogy to the way we live our lives.

Koi will not grow significantly if kept in a small environment. When a koi is freed in a lake, it can stretch out and reach striking proportions. Coined the “Koi Phenomenon,” this space-growth parallel can be used to demonstrate the effects of tearing down boundaries to allow people to stretch and reach their full potential.

Many individuals with disabilities relate this analogy to the challenges they face living in restrictive environments. There once was a pervasive perception that people with developmental disabilities should be kept separate from the general population because they couldn’t lead significant lives. In recent years, however, individuals with developmental disabilities who once lived in institutions are now moving to community-based homes. Similarly many individuals with physical disabilities have experienced a trend toward better accommodations and adaptive equipment. It is clear that many individuals with disabilities are able to work, live and care for themselves when supported well in a natural environment. Caregivers, teachers and family members are beginning to develop and learn appropriate techniques to facilitate this growth.

In an era marked by slow but steady improvement for individuals with disabilities, we see the value in the lessons taught by the Koi Phenomenon. With the changing landscape of our communities we must find new ways to integrate individuals of all ability levels into everyday life. This includes exercise opportunities, leisure activities and recreational pursuits that develop social and physical growth.

Statistics and Social Change

The U.S. Census Bureau estimates one in every five households in America has a person with a disability (2003). This staggering statistic translates into approximately 54 million Americans. Despite this, individuals with physical and mental disabilities are rarely encouraged to participate fully in health and fitness routines. According to government health goals published in Healthy People 2010, 36 percent of Americans say they get no physical activity whatsoever. For individuals with disabilities, who make up 19 percent of the U.S. population, that rate climbs to 56 percent.

The National Center on Physical Activity and Disability (NCPAD) points to numerous research studies demonstrating this disturbing trend. Sadly, the only activity in recent studies in which individuals with disabilities outscored their nondisabled peers was television watching, which they do for more than 4 hours per day (39%) (NCPAD 2003). Despite such numbers, NCPAD director James Rimmer is encouraged by improvements he sees in the changing attitudes of personal fitness trainers (PFTs) and exercise facility program directors. “Attention is finally turning toward health promotion,” he says. “The next big push for social change must include more opportunities and incentives for people with disabilities to engage in higher levels of physical activity throughout the day.”

National organizations such as NCPAD, the American Association on Health and Disability, and the Special Olympics have answered this demand by encouraging others to create enjoyable and rewarding physical activity opportunities that promote substantial improvements in health and quality of life.

“Give me a gym membership and I’ll show you what I can do,” proudly exclaims Carolyn Gaulding, a 54-year-old female with mild developmental disability and cerebral palsy. Echoing the sentiments of countless others, Gaulding suggests that given the chance and proper physical accommodations, she could lead an active lifestyle and “prove everyone else wrong.”

In 1990 the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) became law and helped people like Gaulding accomplish such goals. The ADA, which prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities, generally requires employers, state and local governments and places of public accommodation to offer reasonable services or tools to ensure that people are not discriminated against on the basis of a disability. Rimmer says that integrating individuals with disabilities into community-based exercise programs is also mandated by law through Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, which protects individuals with disabilities from discrimination in programs that receive federal funds from the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the Olympics and Amateur Sports Act. The former mandates physical education programs for children with disabilities in school, while the latter requires the U.S. Olympic Committee to provide amateur athletic contests for athletes with disabilities.

An Untapped Market

Consumers with disabilities control a large purse ($175 billion in discretionary income) and are an untapped spending power (U.S. Census Bureau 2003). In the weak economic climate of recent years, program directors and gym owners have been struggling to maintain membership levels. Those who have designed accessible facilities, products and services make their customers with disabilities feel that their business is valued and appreciated. The U.S. Labor Department predicts that, as this group ages, its purchasing power will only continue to grow. Consequently PFTs and fitness facility managers cannot afford to ignore or stereotype this market. In fact personal trainers and facilities marketing to people with disabilities can reach as many as four in every 10 consumers with disabilities (U.S. Census Bureau 2003).

Don Meisner, owner of Fit 4 Life personal training services, explains, “This is a win-win situation for everyone involved. There is no excuse not to include persons with physical and mental disabilities in the development of fitness programs, camps and gyms that are offered to everyone else.” Meisner, who worked in a residential facility for adults with developmental disabilities while studying for his ACE exam, quickly realized the need for such services and created a successful business model.

Education, Training and Liability

Surprisingly there are few specialized courses in disabilities and physical fitness. In most cases personal trainers and other fitness professionals should posses a degree or experience in kinesiology, physical education or exercise science, with some coursework in disability-adapted exercise science or therapeutic recreation. The range of social and medical issues that individuals with disabilities face when performing physical exercise can provide an intimidating backdrop for even a trained professional. However, no matter the experience level with disability issues, personal trainers and facility managers can help remove the obstacles that traditionally get in the way of gym participation.

As with any new client, it is prudent to carefully screen all special populations by collecting a full medical history and knowing the results of a standard physical exam before beginning any physical activity program. In many cases a more in-depth medical report is also needed due to the complexity of specific disabilities.

For example an individual with Down’s syndrome, a disorder caused by the presence of an extra chromosome 21 and characterized by developmental delays, is more at risk for atlantoaxial instability and gait disturbances due to ankle joint stiffness, hypotonia and flat foot conditions. Persons with cerebral palsy, brain injury, spinal cord injury and stroke may all face spasticity in the quadriceps muscles, leading to knee pain. A person with a spinal cord injury may be at risk for thermoregulatory dysfunction because of his reduced capacity to sweat. At the same time, if there is a high-level spinal cord injury, this person must not exceed a heart rate of 90 beats per minute (National Center on Physical Activity and Disability 2003). In each of these cases, it is obvious why extensive information is needed to identify health issues that might affect a person’s participation. Involving physical therapists, rehab specialists and family members can be helpful in determining the best plan of action.

Faced at times with a dizzying array of “what if” scenarios, fitness professionals often grapple with vague liability laws and fears of increased liability insurance premiums, and thus shy away from working with this population. Adding to this gray area, the ADA does not create standards governing liability in case of injury. If an injury occurs, state negligence laws will govern. The ADA does, however, prohibit facilities from refusing service or gym membership to a person with a disability 8 because of fear of injury to the person. In the long run fitness and recreational facilities face more legal ramifications by not complying with laws governing general access and reasonable accommodations.

The Best Teachers Think “Bigger”

Often called a “soft” or “people” skill, teaching ability is of paramount importance to today’s fitness professional, explains Mark Andrews, owner and founder of Therapeutic Adventures Inc. “The ability to observe students’ learning progress and provide new information in just the right amount and at just the right time is the essence of good teaching,” says Andrews, who is known nationally in the rehabilitation arena for his adaptive outdoor adventure program based on the framework of Outward Bound. “A skilled teacher must sense when students are confused and when they are becoming disinterested; when they are scared and when they are confident; when they are exhausted and when they are up for a challenge. In short a good teacher must step into the learner’s shoes and feel what [he is] feeling,” Andrews says. Simply put, personal trainers must develop an accommodating and all-inclusive attitude—it must be taught, developed, emphasized and renewed. But how does one do this successfully?

1. Use Enthusiasm. Despite the positive progression in the acceptance of individuals with disabilities, those with varying degrees of physical and cognitive deficits are still at times treated like second-class citizens when it comes to exercise and community recreation programs. In a hypercompetitive sports world, it becomes increasingly important to encourage individuals with disabilities—who have never experienced inclusive exercise opportunities—to fully participate alongside nondisabled peers.

Fitness professionals and support staff should not be afraid to offer new suggestions and exercise routines, as many of these choices and opportunities have never been afforded to individuals with disabilities. Present these healthy opportunities with enthusiasm, energy and a positive outlook on what the person can achieve with the right accommodations. It is important for the teacher not to react with pity, anxiety or a variety of other negative emotions when first meeting a person with a disability. At the same time, prompting and encouragement should not be delivered in a condescending or child-like manner, but instead with sincere enthusiasm for the unique skills and characteristics the person possesses.

2. Make Accommodations. “We receive frequent inquires from health and fitness professionals regarding training and accommodations for clients with physical, mental, emotional and learning disabilities. It’s important for trainers and facility managers to understand and be sensitive to the unique needs of this population,” says Gwen Hyatt, owner of DSW Fitness in Phoenix. Hyatt represents the changing attitudes among leading health care professionals as more fitness facilities and classrooms make appropriate accommodations.

For example in recent years The Sports Club in Los Angeles installed chairlifts for two swimming pools, a special rail running along the length of the pool for balance, weight resistance machines that can be adjusted for people in wheelchairs, and several exercise classes designed for individuals with disabilities (Kritz 2002). In making these accommodations, trainers and gym owners need not spend endless amounts of money. In fact equipping staff members with a basic knowledge of disabilities can be even more beneficial than expensive equipment.

A facility with no specific disability programs and equipment can be just as accommodating if trainers are able to meet with a prospective member and openly discuss her goals. At times getting around a problematic area may be as simple as providing visual cues or a picture chart for those who cannot read; physically guiding a participant through a movement if she has trouble with auditory direction; or recruiting a volunteer for the “buddy system” to help a person on and off equipment such as weight resistance machines.

3. Design Age-Appropriate Activities. Individuals with disabilities are already at risk of being stigmatized and should always be encouraged to participate in fitness plans and sporting events that are age appropriate. Childlike games, toys and rewards may perpetuate the myth that a person with a disability needs “special” attention or is “different” from his peers. “Instructors and trainers should not attempt to overcompensate for a disability by creating unnatural learning environments,” says Lucy Cantrell, director of the Hanover ARC, a support group for families and individuals with disabilities in Richmond, Virginia. “Whenever possible a person with a physical or developmental disability should learn by the same rules as a person without a disability. It’s just not natural for a person to receive a sticker or a prize for completing the same task as a nondisabled individual,” she points out.

Understanding this concept, The Chicago Cubs recently created “Buddy Baseball”—an excellent example of an age-appropriate sports model. Partnering with the Chicago Public School’s Inclusion Program, the Cubs make it possible for individuals with disabilities to play on the same team with their able-bodied classmates. Participants work in teams to catch, throw, run and hit—together. Teammates are invited to join the group, regardless of ability or disability, in order to build sportsmanship on a level playing field. Similarly, the Cubs have created “Beep Baseball” for athletes with visual impairments. On this team sighted and nonsighted individuals utilize baseballs that beep and are padded. In this manner individuals with disabilities are encouraged to participate in sporting events that are age appropriate, while experiencing defeats and accomplishments that come along with a normal baseball season.

4. Other Quick Tips

  • Initiate eye contact and introduce yourself. Do this just as you would with any new acquaintance.

  • Acknowledge the person’s presence. Even if she is unable to communicate, let her know you’re “connecting.”

  • Smile. Respond to communicative attempts and observe body language.

  • Shake hands. Even if the person has limited use of his hands or wears an artificial limb, it’s appropriate to shake.

  • Remember that a person with a dis- ability is not “handicapped,” but a “person with a disability.”

  • Respect personal space and understand that a person’s wheelchair is an extension of his body.

  • It is okay to use expressions like “running along” when speaking to the wheelchair user or “good to see you” when speaking to a person who is blind. It is likely that they will use similar expressions.

  • When a wheelchair user transfers out of the wheelchair to a piece of exercise equipment, chair, toilet, car or bed, do not move the wheelchair out of reaching distance.

  • If a person has a developmental dis- ability, concentrate on concrete ideas and skills; avoid abstract concepts.

  • Develop a preview for the next lesson. Provide take-home material and videos to practice new skills.

  • Encourage the person to pick an activity appropriate for the amount of time available, and prioritize the importance of activities.

  • Make instructions clear and concise when training a new participant. Break down directions into small steps or tasks when needed. Tailor instruc- tions to each participant’s level of understanding and retention.

  • Demonstrate whenever possible. Showing is often more effective than telling.

  • Individuals with hyperactivity disorder or developmental disabilities may have difficulty screening out extraneous stimuli. Cease activity to attend to communication and eliminate outside noise, bright lights and/or visual distractions.

  • Keep a journal or chart to record the positive successes and the effort involved in obtaining the goal at hand.

  • Observe the person’s body actions (eyes, face, arms/hands, posture/ stance, etc.) while performing an exercise. A new client may not readily express discomfort.

  • Prompt a new client to keep working on a task even if it is challenging and he may not readily succeed. People with disabilities should not be pitied and handed wins or false accomplishments.

Exercise Examples and Sports Activities

The focus of flexibility training and functionality should be to improve range of motion, balance, coordination and ability to carry out the regular activities of daily living. This routine aspect of physical fitness becomes more important for individuals with disabilities who may not be familiar with thoroughly stretching every muscle group. Extra time and attention on tight muscle groups that have rarely been utilized should be encouraged.

Classes such as yoga, t’ai chi and Pilates should be available to individuals with disabilities in an inclusive and accommodating setting. As with any beginner, trainers should not overemphasize technical terminology and complicated movements. Start with a basic step and progress only when the familiar step has been mastered.

Since its introduction in the 1940s, snow skiing by individuals with physical disabilities has been elevated to new heights. Persons with a wide variety of disabilities (including cerebral palsy, multiple sclerosis, spinal cord injury, amputation, blindness and muscular dystrophy) can all participate (American Association on Health and Disability 2003). Improved technology and adaptive equipment—including sit-skis and mono skis—have led to national competitions and Olympic notoriety.

Penny Rosenblum, author of Fitness Training for Individuals with Visual Impairments, points to her own experience with the United States Association for Blind Athletes as proof of the value in endurance training. Rosenblum, who is blind, has competed in three national events, including the 75-mile El Tour de Tucson Perimeter Cycling event, with a sighted guide. Athletes such as Rosenblum dispel the myth that individuals with disabilities must lead sedentary lifestyles. Endurance training, perhaps more important than any other form of exercise, improves breathing and posture while decreasing the likelihood of secondary disabilities. Lighter weights with more repetitions, weight training machines and cycling equipment are excellent vehicles for a person with a disability wishing to improve her overall health and well-being.

By no means a new sport, wheelchair basketball is currently enjoying a nationwide surge of popularity among individuals with and without disabilities. Action-packed games, like those regularly displayed by the 7-year national champions Dallas Wheelchair Mavericks, are a common occurrence in this well-established sporting arena. Men and women with various physical disabilities compete throughout the United States in hopes of making it to the National Wheelchair Basketball Association (NWBA) championship series.

Just as one would expect to find in the NBA, there are stars, crowd favorites and impressive physical feats. Steve Welch of the Mavericks brought home the MVP award in the most recent championship series, with his 23 points on 11-for-15 shooting statistics. Players like Welch are invited to join gold cup teams, all-star teams and the national men’s team in order to compete in exhibition games and spread the word about this sport.

With this popularity, new teams and conferences have been forming around the country. As evidence of the trend, the Seventh Annual NWBA Basketball Camp and the Officials’ Camp are taking place next summer in Indianapolis.

An Opportunity to Inspire the World to Fitness

Creating exercise programs for individuals with physical and developmental disabilities can be extremely rewarding work. Look around your community for opportunities to instill confidence and physical well-being in those who might otherwise never get a chance to try a new sport or activity and improve their health and fitness. As in the koi analogy, your guidance can create exactly the environment these special populations need to stretch out and reach their full potential!

For the latest research, statistics, sample classes, and more, "Like" IDEA on Facebook here.

Paul M. Spicer

IDEA Author/Presenter
References

American Association on Health and Disability (AAHD). 2003. Snow skiing for the physically disabled. www.aahd.us/exercise.htm; retrieved November 15, 2003.

Kritz, F. 2002. Fit for everyone. The Washington Post, November 12, F1.

National Center on Physical Activity and Disability (NCPAD). 2003. Children with disabilities. www.ncpad.org/whtpprs/childrenwithdisabilities.htm; retrieved November 1, 2003.

Rimmer, J.H., Braddock, D., & Pitetti, K.H. 1996. Research on physical activity and disability: An emerging national priority. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 28, 1366-72.

The Arc. 2003. Introduction to mental retardation. www.thearc.org/faqs/mrqa.html; retrieved October 30, 2003.

U.S. Census Bureau. 2003. Census bureau data on disability. www.census.gov/hhes/www/disable/intro.html; retrieved October 30, 2003.
February 2004

© 2004 by IDEA Health & Fitness Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is strictly prohibited.

Get the award-winning IDEA Fitness Journal delivered to your door every month!

Get IDEA Fitness Journal

Article Comments

Add Comment

1 + 18 =
Cancel
View all questions