Question asked by Susan D'Alonzo 312 days ago
Why is Hot Yoga ok but exercising outside in the heat isn't?
I always advise my bootcampers and personal training clients to be sensible when the temps increase yet it seems that Hot Yoga is an ok thing to do?
Answers (6)
Answered by Jessica Lewis
300 days ago
2
I also advise my clients to be sensible about exercising in the heat and this includes Hot Yoga. In my opinion (in some circles, a not very popular one) it is NOT ok to do Hot Yoga controlled temp or not. The room may be controlled but the individual's body's ability to deal with that heat is not. Muscles can overstretch in an environment where everything is too warm and there is no emphasis on honoring when you feel too hot. It's just supposed to be "good for you" or "a great detox when you know you're hot". Unless teachers or studios can be 100% sure that their students don't have hypertension, are drinking enough water or any number of other factors, they better understand the liability they may be signing themselves up for. Now, I do practice yoga and prefer to have my room warm but I don't purposely heat it to an unnatural temp. It's supposed to be the internal heat that is raised, not external.

I have to agree with Jess. My question back to you was first- who said that it is "OK" and for whom? In the recommendations made for hot yoga- the combination of heat and humidity make the heat index 149 in some cases. Pro football players (yes, working hard- but also- in excellent health and condition) have died at 109.
It's a choice currently, but will it last or won't it and do you want to be a part of the fad or don't you? And why?
Having this conversation with instructors who are committed to it is challenging; they claim they have doctors in their classes. The question is though, are doctors recommending it to their clients?
I think it's more risk than it can promise benefit. Bottom line for us is to first "do no harm."
It's a choice currently, but will it last or won't it and do you want to be a part of the fad or don't you? And why?
Having this conversation with instructors who are committed to it is challenging; they claim they have doctors in their classes. The question is though, are doctors recommending it to their clients?
I think it's more risk than it can promise benefit. Bottom line for us is to first "do no harm."
Comment by Debra Atkinson 299 days ago
0
Hot yoga is preformed in a controlled environment with controlled temps and humidity. Your movement/cardio level is not as high as it would be outside doing a bootcamp, running, etc. Plus outside, you have the sun and varying temps and humidity to deal with.
However, as we are seeing in the Midwest and back East right now, people are being asked to sit still and not exert any physical activity and to stay indoors because it's 102 outside...
Comment by Susan D'Alonzo 312 days ago
Answered by Joanne Duncan-Carnesciali
312 days ago
ExpertMemberVerified
0
Exercising in the heat is very dangerous. One puts him/herself at risk of hyperthermia.
The American College of Sports Medicine has guidelines that one can refer to when implementing activities that will be performed in hot/humid conditions. Following are the guidelines:
Organizational Planning
When clients exercise in hot/humid conditions, fitness facilities and organizations should formulate a standardized heat-stress management plan that incorporates the following considerations:
1. Screening and surveillance of at-risk populations.
2. Environmental assessment (i.e., WBGT index) and criteria for modifying or canceling exercise
3. Heat acclimatization procedures
4. Easy access to fluids
5. Optimized but not maximized fluid intake that (a) matches the volume of fluid consumed to the volume of sweat loss and (b) limits body weight change to
The American College of Sports Medicine has guidelines that one can refer to when implementing activities that will be performed in hot/humid conditions. Following are the guidelines:
Organizational Planning
When clients exercise in hot/humid conditions, fitness facilities and organizations should formulate a standardized heat-stress management plan that incorporates the following considerations:
1. Screening and surveillance of at-risk populations.
2. Environmental assessment (i.e., WBGT index) and criteria for modifying or canceling exercise
3. Heat acclimatization procedures
4. Easy access to fluids
5. Optimized but not maximized fluid intake that (a) matches the volume of fluid consumed to the volume of sweat loss and (b) limits body weight change to
0
The intensity is not too high to tolerate some heat, it is more about warming the body and releasing toxins then pushing a fitness level up...at least that is my understanding.
0
Most Hot Yoga participants are instructed to understand how the body regulates its core temperature, the importance of proper hydration before/during/after, and of heat acclimatization which decreases the risk for heat illness associated with exercising in the heat.
A very good article from the ACE website on the best way to get acclimated to exercising in a hot environment.... such as a hot yoga classhttp://www.acefitness.org/certifiednewsarticle/934/q-and-a-what-s-the-best-way-to-get-acclimated-to/
Comment by Debbie Russell 265 days ago
0
A very good article from the ACE website on the best way to get acclimated to exercising in a hot environment.... such as a hot yoga class
http://www.acefitness.org/certifiednewsarticle/934/q-and-a-what-s-the-be...
http://www.acefitness.org/certifiednewsarticle/934/q-and-a-what-s-the-be...









