Question asked by christopher shaddock 154 days ago
What is a good nutrition plan for a woman with 33% bodyfat, and weighs around 55-60kg?
She lives in Chile now, and used to be in great shape. She says chilean food is pretty heavy, bad fats, etc but I think it is all about what you eat. Any ideas?
Answers (8)
1
Hi Christopher,
since you do not indicate her height, a reference to her weight is ambiguous. To translate for the metrically challenged: 55 kg is about 121 lbs, 60 kg is about 132 lbs. That means that, unless she is very short, her weight may even register as 'normal' on some standards.
That would mean that she should not just look at fat loss but at building muscle through a combination of exercise and diet.
The Chilean food may be heavy but I do not believe that anybody forces her to eat it. Maybe some home-cooking and otherwise smaller portion may be a good idea.
since you do not indicate her height, a reference to her weight is ambiguous. To translate for the metrically challenged: 55 kg is about 121 lbs, 60 kg is about 132 lbs. That means that, unless she is very short, her weight may even register as 'normal' on some standards.
That would mean that she should not just look at fat loss but at building muscle through a combination of exercise and diet.
The Chilean food may be heavy but I do not believe that anybody forces her to eat it. Maybe some home-cooking and otherwise smaller portion may be a good idea.

She is around five foot, three.
Comment by christopher shaddock 154 days ago
At that height-to-weight ratio, her BMI is normal but since she has too much body fat, she needs to start exercising to build muscle while maintaining her weight. I would recommend to her also to have herself checked for cholesterol and other data to make sure that everything is okay there.
Comment by Karin Singleton 153 days ago
1
You don't need a registered dietician to tell her to cut 500 cal per day from her net daily calories...this will result in 3500 cal per week or 1lb of fat loss per week.
This could be 250 cal per day burned working out and 250 cal per day of less food.
What if any working out is she doing?
How active in her daily life is she?
If you want a more specific breakdown of guidelines leg me know.
There is nothing special about nutrition that would require somebody who has no medical conditions to require a dietician for recommendations.
Clean up the diet reduce saturated fats, no trans fats, pay attention to omega 6 and 3 ratios (ideally a 1:1 is best), cut out sugar (Im not talking about fruit), cut out refined grains, eat complete proteins, eat lots of vegetables. Some people will tell you to stop counting calories...I am not one of them. Track everything that crosses the lips..food, water, gum, whatever.
This could be 250 cal per day burned working out and 250 cal per day of less food.
What if any working out is she doing?
How active in her daily life is she?
If you want a more specific breakdown of guidelines leg me know.
There is nothing special about nutrition that would require somebody who has no medical conditions to require a dietician for recommendations.
Clean up the diet reduce saturated fats, no trans fats, pay attention to omega 6 and 3 ratios (ideally a 1:1 is best), cut out sugar (Im not talking about fruit), cut out refined grains, eat complete proteins, eat lots of vegetables. Some people will tell you to stop counting calories...I am not one of them. Track everything that crosses the lips..food, water, gum, whatever.
Thanks Shawn, very helpful.
Comment by christopher shaddock 152 days ago
You have no idea what you are talking about.
Comment by john tucker 151 days ago
LOL actually I do know what I am talking about having taken college sports nutrition classes and studying to be a nutritionist as well as working on two certifications for Nutrition on top of that. Look at the laws John Tucker, they are specific for "nutrition prescription" for special populations. They do not limit ANYBODY from echoing nutritional guidelines that you can find in ANY RD's guidelines for healthy populations. Also look at LeAnn's answer, who is studying to be a RD.
I am not offering a menu plan, I am not designing her meals, so I suggest you read more thoroughly before you stick your foot in your mouth again by accusing somebody like me who has spent the time studying the laws and guidelines of not knowing what I am talking about. lol
I am not offering a menu plan, I am not designing her meals, so I suggest you read more thoroughly before you stick your foot in your mouth again by accusing somebody like me who has spent the time studying the laws and guidelines of not knowing what I am talking about. lol
Comment by Shawn Fears 151 days ago
My point is that a registered dietitian would provide a more comprehensive nutritional program. What you stated is very vague and given her current predicament she would require a nutritional program that would sustain weight loss months after the initiation of diet. Obese individuals need a good nutritional program at the outset as weight loss is attained more so from a balanced diet than by an exercise program. The information you presented does not apply to all individuals as many people attain success with different nutritional programs. Furthermore, diets tend lose their efficacy after as little as three months so when a dietitian does notice a lapse she would be able to respond swiftly. Also genetics does play a factor in how successful a nutritional program is and a low fat diet tends produce varied outcomes with respect to HDL and LDL concentrations. You do not have to post resume every time someone disagrees with you. If she did face any adverse affects from your nutritional advice she could sue you and argue that it is beyond your scope of practice as you are not a dietitian yet. The interpretation of a law is subject to the courts opinion as well.
Comment by john tucker 151 days ago
I apologize for acting inappropriately when I responded to one of your statements.
Comment by john tucker 151 days ago
You didn't state a disagreement you stated I had "no idea what I am talking about" which is a personal attack to my credibility. Also nobody recommended a "low fat" diet but instead a low inflammatory diet through proper fats. If you read my post I also mentioned other factors that affect this as well such as how active she is or what if any working out is she doing. I highly doubt that this person needs anything other than to clean her diet up as is the case with 90% of people looking to drop weight. I don't recommend "diets" but instead a lifestyle change that will affect a persons body. The body becomes its function - if a person eats like crap and doesn't do anything that's how they look, If a person eats clean and is active they will have a body that reflects that. for somebody that is anywhere around 132lbs a 250 cal deficit in nutrition (From maintenance calories) is more than enough to affect the change necessary with a little activity.
I'll clarify for you that I never recommend a low fat diet but instead a healthy fat diet with less saturated fat and no trans fat, and yes I did state vague generalities and offered more specifics if warranted.
You are incorrect in assuming that I can be sued for recommending nutritional guidelines that can be found on the USDA my plate site.
http://www.choosemyplate.gov/
And you are also mistaken that using these recommendations is outside of any trainers scope of practice much less somebody who is a community partner such as myself.
http://www.choosemyplate.gov/partnerships/communitypartnerslist.aspx
Alaska Fitness Solutions is my business.
The problem is everybody is too scared of being sued and the truth is you CAN recommend these guidelines without being a RD or even a nutritionist.
I'll clarify for you that I never recommend a low fat diet but instead a healthy fat diet with less saturated fat and no trans fat, and yes I did state vague generalities and offered more specifics if warranted.
You are incorrect in assuming that I can be sued for recommending nutritional guidelines that can be found on the USDA my plate site.
http://www.choosemyplate.gov/
And you are also mistaken that using these recommendations is outside of any trainers scope of practice much less somebody who is a community partner such as myself.
http://www.choosemyplate.gov/partnerships/communitypartnerslist.aspx
Alaska Fitness Solutions is my business.
The problem is everybody is too scared of being sued and the truth is you CAN recommend these guidelines without being a RD or even a nutritionist.
Comment by Shawn Fears 151 days ago
1
I am currently studying to get my Registered Dietitian and I am a NPC Figure Competitor and I believe that both Shawn and Karin have great answers. However, I am wondering if this person is being honest about their weight. It is reccommended that a women's body fat percentage at a healthy state is 20-24%. That being said a 132lb women with 33% bodyfat seems a little high.
I agree with Shawn in that good fats like EFA's( Essential Fatty Acids 3,6,9) are important in many ways but a healthy fat that we often forget about that will help also is CLA(conjugated linoleic acid omega 6)helps with the simulation and breakdown of stored body fat.
Tracking calories keeps you accountable for sure! You need protein, carbs, and good fats in your diet to keep your blood sugar levels sustained throughout the day so that you don't have sugar spikes and afternoon cravings.
If you want a specific meal plan please contact me through my profile page and GOOD LUCK! ;0)
I agree with Shawn in that good fats like EFA's( Essential Fatty Acids 3,6,9) are important in many ways but a healthy fat that we often forget about that will help also is CLA(conjugated linoleic acid omega 6)helps with the simulation and breakdown of stored body fat.
Tracking calories keeps you accountable for sure! You need protein, carbs, and good fats in your diet to keep your blood sugar levels sustained throughout the day so that you don't have sugar spikes and afternoon cravings.
If you want a specific meal plan please contact me through my profile page and GOOD LUCK! ;0)
I felt that she was not being too honest about her weight, and she has told me what she eats, lots of rice and potatoes. I mentioned to her to cut way back on those and eat foods with the healthy fats. I am working on a nutrition certification, but it is always good to get insight from others. This is not my strong point just yet.
Comment by christopher shaddock 152 days ago
Answered by Ashley Varol (was Berberich)
151 days ago
MemberVerified
1
In the state I live in, Ohio, only Registered Dietitians can provide food recommendations and meal plans. Please be sure you are not opening yourself up to liability issues by providing this information per your states requirements.
That being said, whether you are able to answer this, or you have to refer out, you can always defer back to the Food Guide Pyramid and encourage healthy eating from the main food groups, focusing on fruits and vegetables.
When you mention her culture possibly posing an issue, I'd challenge you to find the healthy components of a Chilean diet: foods that grow there include grapes, apples, pears, onions, peaches, garlic, asparagus, beans, and due to the coast they have a lot of fresh seafood available. There is plenty she could make that is high in nutritional value from these items! Taking someone out of their culture is setting themselves up for disaster; you have to find a way to keep it as part of them, or just as crash diets ultimately fail, so will her new meal plan.
That being said, whether you are able to answer this, or you have to refer out, you can always defer back to the Food Guide Pyramid and encourage healthy eating from the main food groups, focusing on fruits and vegetables.
When you mention her culture possibly posing an issue, I'd challenge you to find the healthy components of a Chilean diet: foods that grow there include grapes, apples, pears, onions, peaches, garlic, asparagus, beans, and due to the coast they have a lot of fresh seafood available. There is plenty she could make that is high in nutritional value from these items! Taking someone out of their culture is setting themselves up for disaster; you have to find a way to keep it as part of them, or just as crash diets ultimately fail, so will her new meal plan.
Answered by Daniel Kosich
150 days ago
1
The answers given are all excellent. Perhaps the most important thing to keep in mind are the ADA's recommendations. No special short-term diet plan. Just keep to the research supported suggestions of about 60% carbs (less than 15% simple sugars), 15-20% protein and 15-20% fats (less than 20% saturated).
And add to that a vigorous exercise program (30-60 min/day, 3-5 days per week). that includes cardio, strength and stretching. Vigorous is the key word.
And add to that a vigorous exercise program (30-60 min/day, 3-5 days per week). that includes cardio, strength and stretching. Vigorous is the key word.
She has started to back in the gym, and she is a black belt in karate but personal issues put her out of training and without divulging too much of personal past she just did not do anything for a few a years, but now she wants to get back on track. She has told me what she eats, a lot of rice and potatoes and I mentioned to her that that needs to eat less of those and more healthier carbs, diversify the fruit and vegetables and drink more water. I will pass all of the information I am receiving on to her. This helps me with my nutrition studies. Thank you again, everyone!
Comment by christopher shaddock 148 days ago
1
I am also a registered dietitian. In most states in the US, one must be licensed to provide a "nutrition prescription," i.e., % of food to be consumed as carbohydrate, protein, and fat, calorie level, vitamins, minerals, water, timing of meals, number of snacks or meals per day, etc. Many factors must be taken into consideration before providing a nutrition plan including age, gender, height, weight, personal goals, medical history including medications, herbals, and supplements, family medical history for risk factor assessment, daily activities, intentional exercise, weight/diet history, menstrual history, sleeping patterns, and more. As Ashley answered, "My Pyramid" is a good place to start. A new model we have is "My Plate," located at www.choosemyplate.gov. I have been having trouble getting on the site lately -- not sure why -- may be my computer.
Answered by christopher shaddock
154 days ago
MemberVerified
0
Thanks Karen!
Please check my addition to the previous answer.
Comment by Karin Singleton 153 days ago









