health fitness
  • Log In / Create Account
  • Renew Membership
  • Join Now
  • View Cart (0)
THE WORLD'S LARGEST ASSOCIATION
FOR FITNESS & WELLNESS PROFESSIONALS
1-800-999-4332 or
  • Home
  • Membership
  • Conferences
  • Insurance
  • CECs/CEUs
  • Articles
  • Videos
  • Store
  • FitFeed
  • Answers
  • FitnessConnect
Ask a health and fitness-related question and receive answers from fitness experts and professionals
Home » IDEA Answers » Need to recommend "HOME” cardio equipment for 63yr w/ knee arthritis. She wants a Bowflex Tread Climber. Spin bike was too
More Info
Question asked by Patty Hartong 559 days ago

Need to recommend "HOME” cardio equipment for 63yr w/ knee arthritis. She wants a Bowflex Tread Climber. Spin bike was too

EquipmentkneeArthritis

I purchased a spin bike, had tried them and liked them, but I find I am not using it because it hurts my knees and it stresses my neck and shoulders from how I must be positioned on the seat/handle bars. I want to get a machine of some kind......I used to have a treadmill and sold it, but I want something aerobic that will also tone.....do you have any recommendations? I am also looking at the Bowflex Tread Climber...it says it combines, stair, elliptical and treadmill for low impact and I really need low impact. If it hurts me, I won't do it.....thanks for any light you can shed.

Add Comment
 
Cancel
 

Answers (8)

Answered by Stephen Landrum 558 days ago
MemberVerified
706 Questions Answered, 7 Questions Asked
1
I have a recumbant bike that allows all the cardio and toning benefits of a spin bike, without the upright (lower back engaging) posture of a typical spin bike. A good one isn't expensive either.
Add Comment
 
Cancel
Answered by Debbie Russell 558 days ago
MemberVerified
187 Questions Answered, 10 Questions Asked
1
Yes I agree with Stephen, I would also suggest switching to a recumbant bike if you do enjoy cycling. When cycling with knee arthritis, be sure the seat is adjusted properly to your height for optimum comfort.

Also the Arc trainer that Marlan suggested is my #1 choice at our gym for arthritic members. Basically this machine allows you to swing your legs in a wide stride and the resistance can be adjusted to give you a harder or easier workout. I prefer the arc trainer to the elliptical because it positions the feet and legs in a slightly different way that removes almost all torque from the knees and hips.

And Andrew mentioned the Rower which works out the upper body, core muscles and legs. There is little to no impact on the knees and hips with this machine and body weight is predominantly supported by the machine, making it an excellent choice of exercise machine for people with bad knees, and yes as long as you don't lock the knees when extending legs.

Now as far as purchasing the Treadclimber, it will also give your knees a gentler low impact workout . Also if you are easily bored it will also help ward off boredom by acting as a stair stepper or a treadmill.

My suggestion is to try them out in the store (especially the Treadclimber due to it's high price tag) and see which one you and your knees like the best! :)

Add Comment
 
Cancel
Answered by Karin Singleton 559 days ago
MemberVerified
1385 Questions Answered, 12 Questions Asked
0
Just about all of my clients with knee problems like the elliptical machines. I would try out different models because there are some variables with resistance, stride length and overall feel. Some also add arm movement which I personally don't like but others do.

I wish you good luck finding the right piece of equipment and I applaud your attitude of not letting knee pain stop you from exercising.
Add Comment
 
Cancel
Answered by Andrew Halligan 559 days ago
Verified
155 Questions Answered, 24 Questions Asked
0
Rowing Machines are also good if you don't lock your knees.
Add Comment
 
Cancel
Answered by Joanne Duncan-Carnesciali 559 days ago
ExpertMemberVerified
1407 Questions Answered, 58 Questions Asked
0
Patty,

I would suggest finding out what are the exercise guidelines for people living with arthritis.

Arthritis is a clinical condition and there are published exercise guidelines for this condition. The ACSM is a good resource. This should serve as a good guide for you in making an informed decision.

All the best.
Add Comment
 
Cancel
Answered by Marlan Eller 559 days ago
Verified
215 Questions Answered, 10 Questions Asked
0
Hi Patty,

As Joanne said, it is a great idea to look up the exercise guidelines for people living with arthritis. This is a general topic, to me, because there are different types of arthritis and different levels of pain, so it'll take some work finding the right set of "specific" guidelines depending on your condition.

I don't know if this will be a helpful resource for you, but consider the following:
http://www.webmd.com/fibromyalgia/fibromyalgia-what-you-need-to-know-10/...

As far as a good low impact machine, consider the Cybex 750AT Total Body Arc Trainer, or one of the lower-end models. Speaking from personal experience, these machines will kick your behind, cardio-wise, and they are fun to be on. As with ellipticals, it can be difficult to get started on at first, but the learning curve is small and it's easy to get accustomed to the machine and begin enjoying the workouts with less fatigue.

I hope that this was somewhat helpful to you, Patty!
Add Comment
 
Cancel
Answered by Fred Waters 266 days ago
2 Questions Answered, 0 Questions Asked
0
I've had an issue with my knee. After 40 years of running I can't believe I am having problems. Anyhow, I've been using the elliptical trainer, without raising the incline. When I raise the incline I can feel the strain. However, I have also been using the treadmill with the incline raised to 10%. I have been following this routine for the last six months and it has gradually allowed my to start running again. Although I limit my running to the treadmill and not the asphalt street.
Add Comment
 
Cancel
Answered by EDWIN MURRAY 60 days ago
2 Questions Answered, 0 Questions Asked
0
Hi Patty. I hurt my knees and ankles after several years of running, but I still needed to find a way to do cardiovascular exercise. After experimenting with a few machines/ routines, I discovered that rowing machines are the answers to all of my prayers, a kick butt cardiovascular workout machine that also builds muscle. Best of all, it's non-weight bearing so my knees are relieved from any abuse they take when I run or do any other weight-bearing exercises. You should check out some rowing machine reviews here: http://www.rowingmachineking.com to find the right one for your needs. Like others have mentioned, a recumbent bike might be a great option for you and they actually have a recumbent bike/ rowing machine hybrid product made by Stamina. Based on personal experience, I would go with a rowing machine because my knees are beat up real bad (especially my left knee) and I can row for an hour and not feel anything on my knees. Take care and hopefully you find a machine that works well with your knee issues.
Add Comment
 
Cancel

Add Answer

Image CAPTCHA
Follow Question

Share this page

Client Share
Tweet

Related Questions

Need to recommend "HOME” cardio equipment for 63yr w/ knee arthritis. She wants a Bowflex Tread Climber. Spin bike was too

8 Answers | Asked by Patty Hartong

What cardio exercises do you recommend for someone with a knee injury?

8 Answers | Asked by Jenilee Quinto

Arthritis knees - is anything other than RICE helpful?

10 Answers | Asked by Sara Mackie Agee

Need ideas for keeping HR elevated with a knee injury

12 Answers | Asked by Addie Kelzer

What is good cardio for clients with limited mobility?

11 Answers | Asked by Melanie Lynum
View All Questions

1 Person is Following this Question

Find a Personal Trainer

IDEA Fitness Connect
  • IDEA FitnessConnect
    • Find a Fitness Professional
    • Find a Personal Trainer
    • Find a Gym
    • Find a Class/Event
    • Fitness Success Stories
    • Fit Pro Blogs
    • FAQs
    • Get Listed
    • FitFeed
    • Media Information
  • Fitness Conferences
    • IDEA World Fitness Convention™
    • Inner IDEA® Conference
    • IDEA Personal Trainer Institute™ East
    • IDEA Personal Trainer Institute™ West
    • Apply to be a Presenter
    • Assistant/Work-Study Program
    • International Representative Program
    • IDEA Awards
  • Publications
    • Article Library
    • IDEA Fitness Journal
    • IDEA Trainer Success
    • IDEA Fitness Manager
    • IDEA Fit Tips
    • IDEA Food & Nutrition Tips
    • IDEA Pilates Today
    • Authors’ Guidelines
    • Republishing Policy
  • About IDEA
    • Contact Us
    • Press
    • History
    • Advertising & Exhibiting
    • Management
    • Careers with IDEA
    • IDEA Experts
    • Joining Forces
  • Career Guide
    • Certifications & Trainings
    • IDEA Answers
    • Continuing Education
    • Liability Insurance
  • Membership
    • Become a Member
    • Renew My Membership
    • Log-in
Be Social: Find us on Facebook follow us on Twitter
Copyright © 2013 IDEA Health & Fitness Association. All rights reserved.
Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Site Map