Question asked by Lisa Kucharski 697 days ago
How do you motivate someone to workout, when you're not training them?
I have clients that only workout when they work with me. I encourage them to do more - take classes, just walk on the treadmill and watch music videos, etc... What is a great way to get them to do more... any suggestions would be helpful.
Answers (9)

2
Have you tried using ChallengeLoop? ChallengeLoop is great because you can have consistent contact with clients when you aren't with them. It allows you to challenge them to achieve a fitness goal and track their progress. You can get to it by going to the "Client Challenges" tool on your "My Account" page on ideafit.com or going to www.challengeloop.com.
Hope this helps!
Hope this helps!
1
By challenging them to "do something" when we're not training together; providing them some examples of the "something to do," and then by asking them to check in with me to let me know what they've "done." Prior to all of this of course, if I've been paying attention to my client and their specific "motivations," I have a pretty good idea of what buttons to push to get them energized.
LaRue, CSCS
www.lecfitness.com
lecfitness@yahoo.com
LaRue, CSCS
www.lecfitness.com
lecfitness@yahoo.com
1
I didn't have time to read the other responses so this may have already been mentioned. Have them train FOR something. Not just asthetics, an activity, event, or sport. It can be as protocol as basketball or as random as hacky-sack. The important thing is they need to be able to see themselves develope at it. Something that drives people to work hard at anything is noticing improvement at it along the way. May have to try a bit of everything till you find it but eventually you will.
Answered by Joanne Duncan-Carnesciali
697 days ago
ExpertMemberVerified
0
Lisa, it is really difficult to motivate someone to change a behavior (as in the case of your client, walk on the treadmill, watch music videos, etc) if you are not aware of what stage of behavior change the client is in.
Your client may very well be in the action stage as far as engaging in physical activity while she is training with you is concerned, but be in different stage of behavior change as far as engaging the physical activity by herself is concerned.
I encourage you to do some research or take a course on Prochaska's and DiClemente's Stages of change model. Learn it well apply it with your clients and you will see how much it will help raise your game as far as being a personal trainer is concerned.
I wish you success with your clients!
Your client may very well be in the action stage as far as engaging in physical activity while she is training with you is concerned, but be in different stage of behavior change as far as engaging the physical activity by herself is concerned.
I encourage you to do some research or take a course on Prochaska's and DiClemente's Stages of change model. Learn it well apply it with your clients and you will see how much it will help raise your game as far as being a personal trainer is concerned.
I wish you success with your clients!

Ive actually done cec's on this exact question. I just wanted to get information on what others have suggested, and get exact info on what it was and how it worked.
Comment by Lisa Kucharski 696 days ago
0
Exercise and working out might not be the first step for someone who needs excessive amounts of motivation to workout. For overweight and obese clients I work with I generally do not recommend exercise right away. Most people are not going to adapt to a lifestyle of exercise from being completely sedentary. I would recommend at looking at physical activity levels and try to increase them. Also, look at a client or patients time in sedentary pursuits and try to substitute that time for active activities that are tailored to the clients lifestyle (gardening, cooking, playing with kids etc) As you progress and notice a change, implementing exercise will become easier and motivation will be easier to obtain. I strongly believe in this method and it really ensures a steady and excellent progression for client to benefit maximally.
Fuel the Movement
JM
Fuel the Movement
JM
Both of these people are not obese, they just don't continue exercising on their own. What have you suggested to someone that worked, and why did it work. I would love to hear a specific event.
Comment by Lisa Kucharski 696 days ago
I should have not said overweight or obese, I should have said sedentary. If someone does not have the benefits and results of attained exercise habits built into themselves as a behavior then they will not appreciate it for its true value and adherence is going to be low. As I mentioned earlier, it is most beneficial to alter sedentary habits and replace them with active habits. That does necessarily mean exercise for sitting and watching tv. TV replaced with gardening, or doing dishes is a great starting point. Or taking a walk on your 15 min break at work, instead of reading. It may not be beneficial to have clients go off on there own (depending on experience) and performing complicated exercise movements. Most likely clients I am assuming you are talking about are inexperienced and deserve the attention of a professional guiding their movements in the fitness center. What they can do it dictate the large component toward their success which is outside of your time and control. I usually DO NOT want my clients going off and doing their own thing because there a point and time when they are ready to go off on there own and execute a complicated exercise movement. This a very detailed process and if you have questions or if I am not clear just let me know.
JM
JM
Comment by Jason Martuscello 696 days ago
I've read the same text book you've read. What I want is for you to tell me how you did this with one client. I want your story, not a textbook answer. I want to see how you and your client accomplished this. I want to get out of "ideal" and see how you made it real.
Comment by Lisa Kucharski 696 days ago
This is not a textbook answer. This method is what I extracted from personal experience and literature in exercise science and psychology. This is what I do with myself, with clients, with friends and with family. That entire thing I wrote is REAL and is far from IDEAL. Most people think the answer to moving to a healthier lifestyle is through exercise, but that is the last if you are sedentary. For example, lets look at my mother, she works 8 hour days 40 hours a week in an office setting. In her free time at home she watches TV and relaxs for the night until bed. She has been accumulating weight and said she wanted help. She thought her solution was with the gym. I know that she has had 4 different memberships in the past and they all expired with minimal usage and adherance. I slowly implemented active changes to her lifestyle to replace sedentary pursuits. A few things are hand washing all her dishes instead of dish washer, parking 5 spots from the closest spot, she watches 2 hours of tv a night so I told her to reduce it 15 min a week or 30 minutes (trying not leave a program cliff hanging). I warned her this is not a rapid weight loss but is the most successful in reaching her goals. It has now been 4-5 months and has lost weight and is starting on an exercise program due to being more vibrant and happy and excited to take it to the next level. It is all about progression ans sequencing. That goes for anything in life. Especially if you want long term success. If it is about the money a lot of people will not take this approach but I believe it is about health and truly helping those who want it!
Hope this helps
JM
Hope this helps
JM
Comment by Jason Martuscello 696 days ago
This is the answer I've been hoping for... what an amazing story. Also, these kind of details are what I'm hoping to hear! Thank you so much. And I hope your mom does well.
Comment by Lisa Kucharski 696 days ago
You are welcome and I myself am a good representation of this type of transitioning. I used to weigh 280 pounds and have successfully lost over 100 pounds. It is what has propelled my ever growing interest into the fitness industry. Thanks again and my mother is doing well! Good luck with your clients!
JM
JM
Comment by Jason Martuscello 696 days ago
Answered by Michelle Gillis-Saltzman
693 days ago
0
Motivation is a tricky thing. It's not something tangible that you can give somebody; it's really not even something you can teach i.e., to be more motivated.
While I applaud your effort to suggest ways for them to be more physically active, when they're not with you, they need something less abstract than that; people that lack the intrinsic pull or desire to be physically active need specific direction, guidance, and some realistic guarantee of a pay off e.g., enlist the support and company of a neighbor or friend to go for a walk after dinner. They'll definitely feel better for the digestion aid, oxygen to the brain, social aspect. You may need to write these things down for them i.e., give them a weekly schedule of physical activities they can do: when, where, for how long, with who...Essentially spell it out for them. And then check off what they've done when you see them next. Discuss how they felt...
I believe I wrote this in another response: the difference between suggesting "doing something else to workout/get exercise" and simply moving one's body (walking to the corner store to get milk, going dancing with friends, etc..) is more than semantic; people have an image, feeling, and/or association with each. Sadly, the latter is a foreign concept to a lot of people I encounter. Our culture seems to have lost the appreciation for moving, just for the sake of moving and the enjoyment (and potential rush or bliss) of it.
Ultimately, individuals need to know why they've started on a particular path: if they are coming to you (even infrequently), they realize there is something of value to the commitment. What you need to do is constantly remind them of the specific things they have told you about how they want to feel, look, think, perform, and achieve...and then remind them again, and again, and again! Always link everything you do with them to the feeling or accomplishment they want.
Hope this helps.
While I applaud your effort to suggest ways for them to be more physically active, when they're not with you, they need something less abstract than that; people that lack the intrinsic pull or desire to be physically active need specific direction, guidance, and some realistic guarantee of a pay off e.g., enlist the support and company of a neighbor or friend to go for a walk after dinner. They'll definitely feel better for the digestion aid, oxygen to the brain, social aspect. You may need to write these things down for them i.e., give them a weekly schedule of physical activities they can do: when, where, for how long, with who...Essentially spell it out for them. And then check off what they've done when you see them next. Discuss how they felt...
I believe I wrote this in another response: the difference between suggesting "doing something else to workout/get exercise" and simply moving one's body (walking to the corner store to get milk, going dancing with friends, etc..) is more than semantic; people have an image, feeling, and/or association with each. Sadly, the latter is a foreign concept to a lot of people I encounter. Our culture seems to have lost the appreciation for moving, just for the sake of moving and the enjoyment (and potential rush or bliss) of it.
Ultimately, individuals need to know why they've started on a particular path: if they are coming to you (even infrequently), they realize there is something of value to the commitment. What you need to do is constantly remind them of the specific things they have told you about how they want to feel, look, think, perform, and achieve...and then remind them again, and again, and again! Always link everything you do with them to the feeling or accomplishment they want.
Hope this helps.
Answered by Danielle Vindez
691 days ago
ExpertMemberVerified
0
Motivation is an art. How would you motivate this client to workout while not in your presence?
We want to empower not encourage dependency. Know your client. Know her history, what she likes and enjoys, what she hates and abhors. Be creative, and be a detective, listen for cues.
Also understand that some clients choose to use you as their reason to show up. If that works for you, and them, and it is healthy, accept it.
Answered by Daniel Kosich
606 days ago
0
Lisa,
You've asked one of the all-time great questions. How do I get somebody to play football if they don't want to play football? I love all of the intricately woven answers. The answer is that your client doesn't give a hoot. So, you know what, just let her/him go on his/her way. We would love them to behave in a certain way. But it will never happen.
Just accept that some things you have to take as the way of the world.
You've asked one of the all-time great questions. How do I get somebody to play football if they don't want to play football? I love all of the intricately woven answers. The answer is that your client doesn't give a hoot. So, you know what, just let her/him go on his/her way. We would love them to behave in a certain way. But it will never happen.
Just accept that some things you have to take as the way of the world.
0
It has to come from them:
Have your clients write out their short term goals
Review them on a regular basis
You can't make anyone do anything, they have to want it.
Have your clients write out their short term goals
Review them on a regular basis
You can't make anyone do anything, they have to want it.













