• Membership
    • Start My FREE Trial
    • Premium Membership w/ Unlimited CECs
    • Personal Trainer Membership
    • Group Fitness Membership
    • Mind-Body Membership
    • Business Membership
    • My Free CECs
    • My Membership
  • Events
    • IDEA Personal Trainer Institute EAST
    • IDEA Personal Trainer Institute SOUTH
    • IDEA World Convention
    • IDEA World Club & Studio Summit
    • IDEA World Nutrition & Behavior Change Summit
    • Virtual Events
  • Insurance
    • Personal Trainer Insurance
    • Group Fitness Insurance
    • Yoga Insurance
    • Club/Studio Insurance
    • Other Insurance
  • Fit Pro Store
    • Need CECs/CEUs
    • Online Courses
    • Certifications & Certificates
    • IDEAfit TV
    • Articles
    • Publications
    • Events
  • Pro Resources
    • IDEAfit TV
    • Continuing Education
    • IDEAfit Social Poster
    • IDEA Client Newsletter
    • Workout Builder
    • Fit Pro Forum
    • Certification & Training Orgs
    • Career Guide
    • Job Board
    • Articles
    • Publications
  • Find Fit Pros
    • Find a Personal Trainer
    • Find a Fitness Class
    • Find a Yoga Teacher
    • Find a Nutritionist or Dietitian
    • Find Gyms/Studios
  • Articles
  • Fit Pro Deals NEW
  • Cart 0
  • Log In / Create Account
  • View Cart (0)
  • Join Now
Log In
Ask a health and fitness-related question and receive answers from fitness experts and professionals
Home » IDEA Answers » Having issues with members turning off fans during class. Aren't fans beneficial? members believe they lose more weight.
More Info
Question asked by Colleen Ingraham 1550 days ago

Having issues with members turning off fans during class. Aren't fans beneficial? members believe they lose more weight.

Client AdviceEquipmentGroup Fitness Classes

I was told fans in a group x class helps to circulate the air and maintain a healthier, cleaner environment. Is this not true? Are fans beneficial? I've tried to teach without them and I almost passed out after 15 minutes of a 60 minute class. Members think they are losing more weight with the fans off since they sweat more.

Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
 

Answers (8)

Answered by Harris Sophocleous 1550 days ago
Member
2722 Questions Answered, 7 Questions Asked
0
Hi Colleen,

To make this as simple as possible since this is your class and you make the rules, if you think the fans need to stay on then that's it. Unless the description of the class states that there will be no fans turned on then there is no reason why you can't keep them on. I'm sure there are other participants who would like the fans turned on during the class. Also, safety and health issues are also in play here.

Best,
Harris
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Janet Weller 1550 days ago
ExpertMemberVerified
284 Questions Answered, 3 Questions Asked
0
Many people mistakenly believe the myth that sweating helps with weight loss. This article has a good explanation to debunk that: http://www.livestrong.com/article/414612-how-does-sweating-make-you-lose.... As Harris mentioned there can be health risks with overheating. If people do not like the fans suggest they position themselves further away. You can also point out that it is easier to work harder when the body is not overheated, and they will burn more calories that way.
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Karin Singleton 1550 days ago
MemberVerified
2973 Questions Answered, 13 Questions Asked
0
Hi Colleen,

it seems that some myths never die. The other day I saw those 'sweat suits' in a store :-(

If you felt almost like passing out after 15 minutes of teaching, you already have the answer whether fans are beneficial. Do not forget that your personal health and safety should be your first concern.

You can point out the risks of overheating, and if your participants still insist, they can put on an extra sweater in your class.

Stay cool.
Karin Singleton
www.meltnc.com
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Colleen Ingraham 1550 days ago
MemberVerified
2 Questions Answered, 2 Questions Asked
0
Thanks for the responses. Some of my members feel the fans are circulating germs and that when the fans on they are getting sick from germs of other members. It's a constant battle. I've had people turn the fans off right after I turned them on and walked back to the front of the room. It's crazy!!!
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Ariadne Greenberg 1550 days ago
MemberVerified
593 Questions Answered, 1 Questions Asked
0
Aside from the sweat to loose weight myth (echoing Karin's sigh here) you might point out that a moist warm environment is a great place to grow fungus and bacteria. Good ventilation is probably even more important than the fans.

I do agree with Harris that you need to make an executive decision on this. A good start is to ask the facility if there is a rule about the fans/temperature etc, and then let your students know that that is the policy and you must enforce it.

I teach yoga at a place that has one room that is shared with aerobics. The temperature is kept cooler, with which I agree. It would be more comfortable for us to be 10 degrees warmer, but it would be dangerous for them!

Good luck with this.
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Christine Hales 1550 days ago
MemberVerified
957 Questions Answered, 8 Questions Asked
0
Hi Colleen,

When I teach my classes I am in control of the fans. I always accommodate a request to turn them on because my concern is overheating. (I let my class know this). You will always have some who don't want them on--you can't please everyone! Stand your ground and do what is best for the class. They will respect you for it.

Take care and good luck!

Christine
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by LaRue Cook 1549 days ago
MemberVerified
1357 Questions Answered, 5 Questions Asked
0
Hi Colleen. While your members are correct that they may lose more 'water weight' without fans or other cooling devices, they need to know that this 'loss' is very temporary since it returns once they rehydrate. But, aside from this fallacy, the truth is not overheating during their exercise is simply safer for them and I agree that I would simply make use of the fans, or at least maintaining the workout areas/gym at a safe and recommended temperature MANDATORY - end of story. After all, there are gym standards out there for recommended temperatures in the gym.

I hope that this helps.

LaRue, CSCS
www.lecfitness.com
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Susan Dalonzo 1547 days ago
MemberVerified
1937 Questions Answered, 22 Questions Asked
0
When I taught inside we had the fan corner and the non fan corner.

People are very adamant about these things.

Personally, I like air circulating the smells out and cooling people off.

As for weight loss? total myth!

Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel

Add Answer

Image CAPTCHA
Follow Question

Share this page

Client Share
Tweet

Related Questions

Having issues with members turning off fans during class. Aren't fans beneficial? members believe they lose more weight.

8 Answers | Asked by Colleen Ingraham

Has anyone held classes that members pay as they lose weight? I was thinking of offering classes that members pay $10/lb lost.

10 Answers | Asked by Jim Hensrud

What is the best fan (mist, ceiling, floor) for group fitness rooms (classes & training) - one is 60 sq ft, the other 1800?

2 Answers | Asked by Lori Decker

I teach a beginning weight training class for (mostly) seniors (50+). One class member has been diagnosed with osteoporosis.

7 Answers | Asked by Janet Hagen

Are weighted vests beneficial ?

9 Answers | Asked by Teresa Kelts
View All Questions

1 Person is Following this Question

Find a Personal Trainer

IDEA Fitness Connect