• Membership
    • Start My FREE Trial
    • Premium Membership w/ Unlimited CECs
    • Personal Trainer Membership
    • Group Fitness Membership
    • Mind-Body Membership
    • Business Membership
    • My Free CECs
    • My Membership
  • Events
    • IDEA Personal Trainer Institute EAST
    • IDEA Personal Trainer Institute SOUTH
    • IDEA World Convention
    • IDEA World Club & Studio Summit
    • IDEA World Nutrition & Behavior Change Summit
    • Virtual Events
  • Insurance
    • Personal Trainer Insurance
    • Group Fitness Insurance
    • Yoga Insurance
    • Club/Studio Insurance
    • Other Insurance
  • Fit Pro Store
    • Need CECs/CEUs
    • Online Courses
    • Certifications & Certificates
    • IDEAfit TV
    • Articles
    • Publications
    • Events
  • Pro Resources
    • IDEAfit TV
    • Continuing Education
    • IDEAfit Social Poster
    • IDEA Client Newsletter
    • Workout Builder
    • Fit Pro Forum
    • Certification & Training Orgs
    • Career Guide
    • Job Board
    • Articles
    • Publications
  • Find Fit Pros
    • Find a Personal Trainer
    • Find a Fitness Class
    • Find a Yoga Teacher
    • Find a Nutritionist or Dietitian
    • Find Gyms/Studios
  • Articles
  • Fit Pro Deals NEW
  • Cart 0
  • Log In / Create Account
  • View Cart (0)
  • Join Now
Log In
Ask a health and fitness-related question and receive answers from fitness experts and professionals
Home » IDEA Answers » Being a trainer with serious back issues
More Info
Question asked by Patty Hartong 1974 days ago

Being a trainer with serious back issues

Back InjuryCareer Fitness InstructorBack

Hello everyone – Just went to my back orthopedic surgeon and was told my 51 year old back is a mess. (I went for my sore foot and they wanted to address the lumbar spine so needless to say – I was very shocked to find out my back is horrible shape). I do have minimum back pain from an accident 5 years ago and scoliosis (also I just found out).
My question – Is there anyone else out there with a serious back issue who is still teaching Group exercise classes/Zumba and Personal Training? I don’t want to stop what I’m doing (and was told to go easy on jumping and heavy lifting) but I also do not want to make things worse. NOTE: I have a several 4mm and under bulging dics and a 6mm bulging disc on L5/S1 – along with spinal stenosis up and down my spine. My L1/2 is the worst – just about bone on bone.
Just looking for a fellow trainer with similar issues. Thanks! Patty

Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
 

Answers (16)

Answered by Karin Singleton 1974 days ago
MemberVerified
2973 Questions Answered, 13 Questions Asked
1
Hi Patty,

I can only imagine how scared you are. Going to the doctor because your foot hurts and walking out in the belief that your lower back is only one step away from a major disaster.

Considering what you have been doing up to this point and that you are without symptoms, you should ask a lot of questions of different medical providers. Get second opinions and third opinions if necessary. Listen also to your own inner voice. You know your body better than anybody else.

My own bit of history: in 1999, I was told that I would have to wear a functional brace for the rest of my life after an ankle injury. That same year, I walked a marathon (without the brace), and my foot has been just fine ever since. I know it's not the same as your back but I am sure glad I decided not to believe what I was told.

Wishing you all the best.
Karin Singleton
www.meltnc.com
1 Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Janet Weller 1973 days ago
ExpertMemberVerified
284 Questions Answered, 3 Questions Asked
1
I agree with Karin about going for other opinions. Backs are a complex issue, and what shows on the XRay/MRI's often does not match the pain the person feels. Sounds like that is the case with you. There are a high percentage of people with herniated/ bulging discs etc, with NO pain, and those with "normal" spines who have tremendous pain. Just because the back looks bad on scans does not mean you need to treat it.
1 Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Patty Hartong 1973 days ago
MemberVerified
7 Questions Answered, 11 Questions Asked
1
THANKS everyone! I feel better! I love the statement - "Just because the back looks bad on scans does not mean you need to treat it". I’m not in pain – I can do anything and everything I want to do. I'm a healthy and active 51 year old athlete and love my job - my clients - my students. I appreciate everyone’s comments.
Time to go back to thinking about my clients and no so much about myself“ !!
2 Comments
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Danielle Marquez 1971 days ago
Member
7 Questions Answered, 7 Questions Asked
1
I have issues with a bulging disc, and there's several things I don't do anymore because the exercises always strain it. However, I have learned to use verbal cues alot more now as opposed to demonstrating. Luckily, I teach Pilates and group strength--not sure how much verbal-only you can do with zumba.

Either way, my understanding is that some herniations and bulging discs might be asymptomatic. I would advise you to stop doing (or at least modify) whatever it is that is hurting you, especially your foot, or that might start to hurt in the future. Don't work through it like I did. I ignored some of the signs my body was giving me and ended up not being able to bend or sit down for 2 weeks. Now THAT was really hard on my training job. It got better, but I know now to lay off any time I get a bad twinge.

BTW, I do some pretty serious kettlebell and TRX stuff, so a disc issue is not a death sentence. You just need to have proper biomechanics and a good mind/body awareness.

Good luck, and glad you're feeling pretty good!
1 Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Jill Brown 1709 days ago
MemberVerified
9 Questions Answered, 1 Questions Asked
1
I just noticed this query - I would have chimed in ages ago! I had 2 spine surgeries in 2003 and 2007 (in my neck - a fusion and a foraminotomy for the bone spurs). I have stenosis in both my neck and low back. I am only 45, but was diagnosed 10 years ago after a car accident where the right side of my body went numb.
Do I still teach? You betcha! Boot Camps (with plenty of plyos and HIITs), Cycling and more, but I do have to be more careful of course and I have made my Core a fortress. After I recovered from the first surgery in '03, I got certified by STOTT Pilates which was a blessing.
I don't run of course, or do things which strain the neck (because that's where my surgery was) like road cycling, boxing (where someone is punching back!), or rock climbing for example.
But it has made me a much better trainer for my clients who do suffer from back pain as I have done much to educate myself and worked with my physical therapist at length to learn the best exercises and stretches for this disease.
Understanding where your pain is coming from and what is causing it is key. You MUST keep the area strong and know when you can and should push your strength limits. Allowing the muscles to weaken will only make it worse!
Stay active my friend!
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Patty Hartong 1974 days ago
MemberVerified
7 Questions Answered, 11 Questions Asked
0
PS - More details: I went to my foot Dr (not a back dr) and was sent for a nerve conduction test (which turned out good) and a MRI of the lumbar spine. He wasn’t to see if my spine was causing my foot pain (it was not).
They said – go to Physical Therapy (I also teach yoga). If that doesn’t work – get epidural injections – and then surgery if nothing works. This is crazy – I feel fine and have no “real pain” or physical limitations.
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by LaRue Cook 1974 days ago
MemberVerified
1357 Questions Answered, 5 Questions Asked
0
Hi Patty. I'm sorry to hear about your diagnosis. While I do not have this issue, I wanted to chime in with my opinion. Does your physician know what you do for a living? And if so, given your profession, what has been his/her advice moving forward? I know that you're wanting to hear from other trainers out there who may be experiencing "the same thing," but as you know, there isn't such thing as the same thing when it comes to our bodies and how they deal with a condition or illness. What another trainer may be experiencing may or may not have any connection or relation to how your body responds or how you should proceed. I hope that you rely more on your own medical professional team (physicians, therapists etc) in deciding what you need to do.

I wish you the best, and continued success in your career. Good luck!

LaRue, CSCS
www.lecfitness.com
larue.cook@lecfitness.com
1 Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Joanne Duncan-Carnesciali 1973 days ago
ExpertMemberVerified
1430 Questions Answered, 67 Questions Asked
0
Hello Patty,

I am curious to know whether you saw the diagnostic x-rays and MRI? If you haven't please request to see them.

However, on another note, I'd like to share something with you that is helpful to me when I find myself facing challenges where it appears that I am between a rock and a hard place...

It might seem off the beaten track, however, have you ever considered hiring a life coach? I ask this because at times when it appears there is no way out it might benefit us to speak with someone who can assist us in seeing the possibilities or the silver lining in the situation we deem to be challenging.

To encourage you, I'd like to share something that the 20th century psychiatrist Carl Jung described in order to encourage his patients to acknowledge their strengths and imagine possibilities in order to outgrow their problems. He said:

"The greatest and most important problems of life are all in a certain sense insoluble. They can never be solved, but only outgrown. This outgrowing as I formerly called it, on further experience, was seen to consist in a new level of consciousness. Some higher or wider interest arose on the person's horizon and through this widening of view the insoluble problem lost its urgency. It was not solved logically in its own terms, but faded out when confronted with a new and strong life-tendency."

I encourage you, with the assistance of a life coach to to widen your view and find your new and strong life-tendency. I believe with all my heart there are great things awaiting you!

Best.
2 Comments
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by NatalieSmith NAPS 2 B Fit 1973 days ago
Verified
2467 Questions Answered, 13 Questions Asked
0
Hello Patty,

I applaud your enthusiasm; keep up the great spirit. You know your body better than anyone else; so, go with your gut feeling; that is what I do for my feet.

I find that not all doctors understand the difference between physical therapists and personal trainers and prefer to give me the option of pain medicine, which I deny.

Your training background will help you decide when to take it easy.

As a trainer, I do not need to do the workout with the class, as it is their workout, not mine. I only need to instruct; therefore, I take advantage of walking around the class to check on the clients.

This is what helps me when my feet are acting up. I do not have a back condition... that I know of; but, I need to be careful of my aging body, knowing there are back problems in the family.

Take care and thanks for sharing your courageous and inspiring story.
2 Comments
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Susan Dalonzo 1973 days ago
MemberVerified
1937 Questions Answered, 22 Questions Asked
0
Are you in pain? Is your back limiting your ability to teach?
1 Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Bryant Seton 1973 days ago
861 Questions Answered, 9 Questions Asked
0
As long as your back doesn't negatively effect your health or the training of your clients/classes I don't think this would be a problem.
1 Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Jocelyn Martin 1966 days ago
Verified
445 Questions Answered, 15 Questions Asked
0
I agree with the other who say you may want to seek a second opinion.

Medicine is both a science and an art. There is so much we are still learning about the capabilities of the human body. What may cause one person pain and discomfort, may not to some one else. Everyone's body aligns and performs differently.

And just as there is a wide spectrum of personal trainers, the same can be said of doctors. See someone else. Tell them what you were told, tell them how you currently feel, and ask lots of questions till you get answers that mesh with what your body is telling you.

I tell my liens that they are the only ones who know their body best. If this diagnosis doesn't sound or feel right to you, go looking for one that does!
1 Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Robyn Caruso 1964 days ago
Verified
6 Questions Answered, 4 Questions Asked
0
Hi Patty,

I have an injury from about 8 years ago and I am now 33. I have two herniated disks at level L4/L5 and L5/S1. I also have a bulging disk at T12. I have been a trainer for 13 years but do have to watch what I am doing. Please listen to your doctor and what they say. I started out with really bad pain and now it is gone but I have to keep my back and core strong.

You want to be careful with degeneration of the disks as you can get pain later on. Your back may also tell you if you have done to much. I will get warning signs. I just wanted to chime in because when/if you do get pain it is very painful. I used to do alot more high impact exercise but had to stop. I can do high impact classes a couple times a week. For me, possibly getting pain again in the future isn't worth it. Along with pain you may also get strength loss, bad pain when you cough or laugh, numbness and tingling, not being able o sit, stand, or sleep etc ect. Try to keep yourself pain free for as long as you can. If you get pain it could take up to a year or more to go away. It took me about a year and two months. There are alot of people who are pain free in the beginning. Just be careful.
1 Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Danielle Vindez 1942 days ago
ExpertMemberVerified
424 Questions Answered, 5 Questions Asked
0
Physicians are valid and reliable advisors. We want to consider their advice as part of our decision making process and devise something we can live with successfully. This does not mean we are irresponsible, but it means we weigh and consider many variables. This is critical thinking, making a decision based on valid information, and unbiased assumptions.
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Daniel Kosich 1626 days ago
1101 Questions Answered, 0 Questions Asked
0
Great responses. Susan's 2 questions for you are certainly relevant and important. I would avoid exercises and movements that lead to acute or chronic pain. Also, use your knowledge of lifting techniques to lift objects, weights, etc. using primarily the quads and gluts, not the lower paraspinals.

Good luck.
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel
Answered by Martin Petrofes 1134 days ago
Verified
2121 Questions Answered, 4 Questions Asked
0
It has been a long time since you posted this. I hope all is going well.

I have had numerous back, neck and head injuries starting with a fall down a flight of stairs as a toddler and the last injury was in a spill on while mountain biking. I have mostly good days, but do occasionally over extend myself and have to deal with the repercussions. But back injury and maintenance is an ongoing progression. I have learned so much about being more mindful and more judicious when it comes to my activities.

Most people do adjust and improve, but moving is very important. I spend very little time sitting and have learned to adjust my sleeping position according to where I feel the most out of whack at any one time. I use and design treadmill desks, which I find to be fantastic for everyone as well as for those of us with back issues (which is a very large population). I would be happy to give you advice if you are still in need of assistance. Contact me through my profile if you are interested.
Add Comment
 
Image CAPTCHA
Cancel

Add Answer

Image CAPTCHA
Follow Question

Share this page

Client Share
Tweet

Related Questions

Being a trainer with serious back issues

16 Answers | Asked by Patty Hartong

300 Lbs client, I need serious advice !

9 Answers | Asked by Hisham El Sherbiny

Training a Client with a lower back issue

11 Answers | Asked by Alyassia Ruiz

Are there negative issues with deep squats for the over 40 crowd starting back into exercise?

11 Answers | Asked by Rick Almand

Recommended exercises for someone with back and knee issues?

10 Answers | Asked by Steve Leon
View All Questions

2 People are Following this Question

Find a Personal Trainer

IDEA Fitness Connect